Microsoft Hits a Snag Over AI-Driven Layoffs! The Court Upheld the Business Transformation, So Why Was the Dismissal Still Unlawful? Three Lessons Corporate HR Must Remember
I often remind corporate HR leaders: While AI can certainly replace certain tasks, companies cannot use it as an excuse to bypass their legal obligation to reassign affected employees!
On October 30, 2026, Civil Judgment No. 97 of 2025 (114th Year, Zhong-Lao-Su No. 97) rendered by the Taiwan Taipei District Court sounded a wake-up call for companies undergoing AI transformation, organizational restructuring, and workforce downsizing.
Microsoft Taiwan laid off a female Account Executive earning a monthly salary of NT$166,500 after introducing AI tools and adjusting its business model. Although the court recognized that the advancement of AI technology had indeed altered the nature of the company's business and created a necessity to reduce headcount, it still ruled the dismissal unlawful, confirmed the continued existence of the employment relationship, and ordered the company to continue paying her wages and making labor pension contributions.
What warrants the greatest attention from businesses in this ruling is not that the court rejected AI adoption as a valid ground for layoffs, but that it clearly established the following principle:
Employers have the right to leverage AI to boost efficiency and restructure organizations, yet they cannot merely prove why layoffs are necessary—they must also prove that they have fulfilled their duty of reassignment.
When introducing AI and adjusting headcount, corporate decision-makers and HR leaders are advised to examine the following three key takeaways.
(For labor law compliance training, workshops on reasonable management vs. workplace bullying boundaries, practical drills for grievance handling and investigators, continuing education credit certification for board members, external committee members for workplace bullying and sexual harassment, practical PIP workflow workshops, and representation in litigation and mediation proceedings, please contact Yesin Law Firm at Tel: 02-2515-6822 or visit https://www.yesinlaw.com.)
1. Efficiency gains from AI can constitute a lawful ground for severance, provided the company proves substantive changes in its business
Article 11, Subparagraph 4 of the Labor Standards Act stipulates that an employer may terminate a labor contract with advance notice only when a change in the nature of the business necessitates a reduction in the workforce, and there is no suitable work available for reassigning the affected employees.
In its reasoning, the court elaborated on "a change in the nature of the business" as follows: A change in the nature of business certainly encompasses changes to the business items operated by the employer; it also includes changes in the technologies, methods, or means of operating the business that result in structural or substantive alterations to all or part of the operations. Therefore, when an employer adopts a different operational model out of business judgment, or out of necessity to respond to market competition and enhance productivity and efficiency, resulting in structural or substantive alterations to the execution of that business segment, it also falls within the scope of a change in the nature of business (cf. Supreme Court Civil Judgments No. 1821 of 2009 [98 Tai-Shang No. 1821] and No. 144 of 2016 [105 Tai-Shang No. 144]). Furthermore, beyond focusing on changes to the original business types (nature) of all or part of a department, a change in the nature of business also involves adjustments to the organizational and operational structure (cf. Supreme Court Civil Judgment No. 3322 of 2021 [110 Tai-Shang No. 3322]).
During the trial, Microsoft argued that following the adoption of AI tools such as Copilot, sales personnel saw improved efficiency in data analysis and client service, prompting a revision of staffing standards.
Previously, sales headcount was allocated based on revenue contribution; this was shifted to an allocation based on client count, under which each Account Executive was, in principle, required to manage at least three major accounts. Because the Financial Services Industry division had only ten key accounts, it became necessary to reduce the team by one Account Executive.
The court accepted this argument, holding that AI technology had indeed prompted the company to alter its mode of operation, thereby satisfying the statutory requirements of a change in the nature of business and the necessity to reduce headcount.
The original text of the judgment states: "The Defendant (Microsoft), due to the application of AI technology, reduced and adjusted its manpower requirements and had the necessity to decrease the original number of AEs in the Defendant's EC (Enterprise Commercial) division. This constituted a change in business operations in response to industry trends. Thus, the Defendant's defense that the dismissal was due to a change in the nature of business rather than an arbitrary layoff of the Plaintiff (the employee) is not without merit. Accordingly, in light of the aforementioned principles, it is established that the Defendant objectively had the necessity to reduce its workforce due to the said change in the nature of business."
This signifies that companies do not have to wait until they suffer financial losses, shut down plants, or eliminate an entire department before they can lawfully adjust their workforce.
2. Passively sharing a job portal link does not equate to fulfilling the duty of reassignment
Microsoft contended that it had regularly sent internal job listings and that supervisors had also suggested other roles for the Plaintiff's reference.
However, the court held that these measures were still insufficient to prove that the company had fulfilled its duty of reassignment.
The reason is that an employer must proactively identify suitable roles, rather than requiring the employee to apply on their own.
The court reasoned as follows: The so-called "suitable work" refers to positions available at the time of severance, or within a reasonably proximate period before or after severance, that offer working conditions comparable to those at the time of the employee's layoff, are within the employee's capabilities to perform, and are acceptable to the employee (cf. Supreme Court Civil Judgment No. 957 of 2018 [107 Tai-Shang No. 957]). Furthermore, "having no suitable work available for reassignment" refers to situations where the employer has proactively sought to reassign the employee without success—not a situation where the employee must seek reassignment on their own or separately apply to the employer for other openings.
More crucially, the court found that the company had not previously made active efforts to help sales personnel transition across industry verticals through training, instead favoring candidates who already possessed immediate industry experience and could rapidly generate sales.
This "plug-and-play" mindset toward reassignment does not necessarily align with the principle of dismissal as a last resort (ultima ratio).
Companies cannot unilaterally and arbitrarily conclude that reassignment is impossible merely because an employee currently lacks certain skills; rather, they must reasonably assess whether the employee could transition into the role with proper training and coaching.
Of course, the law does not require employers to provide unlimited training, nor does it require them to create non-existent positions.
However, employers must at least provide a concrete evaluation explaining why the employee would still be unable to perform the role even after reasonable training.
HR is advised to establish a three-stage reassignment process for AI transformation:
Stage 1: Inventory the employee's existing skills, complete work history, and potential roles for transfer.
Stage 2: Assess the gap between the employee's skills and job requirements, and arrange a reasonable period of AI training, on-the-job coaching, and cross-departmental interviews.
Stage 3: Document the reassignment outcomes, the employee's preferences, and specific reasons why a transfer was unfeasible; only proceed with evaluating lawful severance after confirming that no reasonable alternatives exist.
These records will serve as vital evidence for the company in the event of a labor dispute.
3. Continuing external recruitment prior to layoffs can become key evidence of breaching the duty of reassignment
What merits the closest attention in this case is the court's strict scrutiny of the company's recruitment timeline prior to the layoff.
Microsoft knew as early as April 2025 that its AI transformation could lead to a reduction in sales headcount, yet it still externally hired a new Account Executive for another industry vertical on June 12, before deciding to lay off the Plaintiff on July 1.
The court held that since the layoffs were already foreseeable, the company should have considered temporarily holding those vacancies open and determining whether affected employees could be reassigned before recruiting externally.
More importantly, company supervisors assumed the Plaintiff only had financial sector experience and was therefore unsuitable for transfer to the telecommunications, transportation, and distribution industry groups.
However, the court found that the Plaintiff had previously served clients in the retail logistics and transportation/shipping sectors, and that internal precedents existed of financial sector Account Executives successfully transferring to other industry groups.
This undermined the credibility of the company's assertion that the employee was unqualified for other openings.
The court further noted that suitable work is not limited to vacancies existing on the exact day of severance, but must also encompass positions with comparable working conditions that the employee is capable of performing and willing to accept within a reasonably proximate period before and after severance.
Consequently, a company cannot recruit new hires on one hand while claiming there are no jobs available to reassign laid-off employees on the other.
Before initiating layoffs, HR should establish mechanisms for cross-departmental vacancy inventories, comprehensive employee career audits, and transfer suitability assessments.
In particular, planned requisitions, approved roles where candidates have not yet onboarded, and upcoming vacancies should all be included in the evaluation to avoid heightening dismissal disputes due to recruitment timing.
Attorney Yeh-Hsin Chen's Key TakeawayWhat AI transformation truly tests is how companies treat employees whose roles are reshaped by technology
This ruling reminds businesses that AI transformation cannot rely solely on technological upgrades; it must be accompanied by simultaneous upgrades to human resource management and labor compliance systems.
In this case, the court confirmed the continued existence of the employment relationship, requiring the employer to pay NT$166,500 in monthly wages plus NT$9,000 in monthly labor pension contributions. Although the NT$886,914 in severance already paid was permitted to be offset against back-pay claims, it could not eliminate the ongoing risks stemming from an unlawful dismissal.
For enterprises, the truly high cost is not the expense of retraining employees for new roles, but the labor compliance risk costs incurred by failing to conduct proper reassignment assessments.
I recommend that every HR leader do one thing before the end of 2026: require each department to submit a workforce demand projection plan for the first half of 2027 following AI adoption, while simultaneously mapping out transfer opportunities and training needs for potentially affected employees.
Now that AI can already help companies redesign workflows, are our HR systems also ready to redesign employees' careers—rather than merely designing their offboarding process?

Comments